Hall of Fame
| Year | Name | Sport | | | | |
| 1973 | Anthony Crino | Basketball Honor | | | | |
| Nathaniel Echols | Basketball Honor | | | | |
| Carl Lorello | Basketball Honor | | | | |
| Hugh Cusack | Writer/Leader | | | | |
| 1974 | Frank Drone | Basketball Honor | | | | |
| 1975 | Quentin Amati | Basketball Honor | | | | |
| Ira Lerner | Writer/Leader | | | | |
| 1976 | Hugh Guidi | Basketball Honor | | | | |
| Norman Finkelstein | Coaching Honor | | | | |
| Joseph Worzel | Writer/Leader | | | | |
| 1977 | John Bingham | Basketball Honor | | | | |
| Joseph Jezerski | Basketball Honor | | | | |
| Stephen Renick | Basketball Honor | | | | |
| Eugene Kier | Writer/Leader | | | | |
| Alfred Hoffmeister | Old Timer | | | | |
| 1978 | Murray Finkelstein | Writer/Leader | | | | |
| 1979 | No Selection | | | | | |
| 1980 | Anthony Czerkies | Basketball Honor | | | | |
| 1981 | Michael Dorrell | Basketball Honor | | | | |
| Kevin Mulligan | Basketball Honor | | | | |
| John Woods | Softball Honor | | | | |
| Frederick Carter | Coaching Honor | | | | |
| Max Friedman | Writer/Leader | | | | |
| Stanley Nabozynz | Old Timer | | | | |
| 1982 | Daniel Fine | Basketball Honor | | | | |
| 1983 | Nicholas DiLeo | Softball Honor | | | | |
| James Carlino | Softball Honor | | | | |
| Barry Frederick | Softball Honor | | | | |
| Frederick Carter** | Softball Honor | | | | |
| Richard Osgood | Softball Honor | | | | |
| James Lorello | Softball Honor | | | | |
| Glenn Anderson | Basketball Honor | | | | |
| Frank Sheldone | Basketball Honor | | | | |
| George Trudeau | Basketball Honor | | | | |
| Francis Tadak | Basketball Honor | | | | |
| Edward Sedoma | Basketball Honor | | | | |
| Robert Shepard | Basketball Honor | | | | |
| 1985 | Gwen Alabaster Rocque | Playing Honor | | | | |
| Sara Wummer | Athlete Honor | | | | |
| Daniel Pordum | Coaching Honor | | | | |
| Thomas Cooney | Writer/Leader | | | | |
| Samuel Cohen | Old Timer | | | | |
| Eric Cooper | Softball Honor | | | | |
| Phil Scherzinger | Softball Honor | | | | |
| Paul Kaessler** | Softball Honor | | | | |
| 1987 | Jacab Antal | Basketball Honor | | | | |
| Paul Kaessler | Basketball Honor | | | | |
| Anthony Sansone | Writer/Leader | | | | |
| Vito Manzella | Writer/Leader | | | | |
| Stanley Siegel | Writer/Leader | | | | |
| Walter Schulman | Writer/Leader | | | | |
| Albert Berke | Writer/Leader | | | | |
| 1989 | Richard Rooney | Basketball Honor | | | | |
| Egidio "Al" Lepre | Coaching Honor | | | | |
| Donald C. Zulauf | Writer/Leader | | | | |
| 1990 | William Benz | Basketball Honor | | | | |
| Francis A. Berst | Basketball Honor | | | | |
| Barry Siekierka | Basketball Honor | | | | |
| William L. Flanders | Coaching Honor | | | | |
| Daniel Chiarello | Writer/Leader | | | | |
| Joseph Hosinski | Old Timer | | | | |
| 1991 | Lawrence Thorpe | Basketball Honor | | | | |
| Charles Maucere | Coaching Honor | | | | |
| Rocco DiNapolis | Writer/Leader | | | | |
| 1992 | Edward Jenkins, Jr. | Writer/Leader | | | | |
| Stewart Gerlis | Softball Honor | | | | |
| 1993 | Robert Williams | Basketball Honor | | | | |
| 2001 | Alex Piacentini | Basketball Honor | | | | |
| Thomas Samuels | Basketball Honor | | | | |
| Joseph F. Black | Basketball Honor | | | | |
| Anthony Zacharewicz | Basketball Honor | | | | |
| Francis McDermott | Coaching Honor | | | | |
| Robert A. Loeffler | Softball Honor | | | | |
| Stanley J. Nasukiewicz | Softball Honor | | | | |
| 2008 | Michael Zollo | Basketball Honor | | | | |
| Sears Cummings | Writer/Leader | | | | |
